Sahib Salaam Travels made one at a time · India
Jaisalmer Fort in the late afternoon
A zone · western Rajasthan

The Thar,
by subtraction.

Every other zone I take people to is about addition — one more valley, one more monastery. This one is the opposite. The whole trip is an exercise in removing things: people, then light, then sound, until there is nothing left but the ground and the sky. Getting to that takes a fortnight and a particular week of the month, and almost nobody bothers.

Dunes in the Thar desert
Patwon ki Haveli, Jaisalmer
Demoiselle cranes at Khichan
The zone holdsJodhpur & Osian · Khichan · Jaisalmer · the Desert National Park · the deep desert · Barmer · Bikaner
SeasonOctober to March. Summer here runs to 45–50°C and is not a holiday.
Best monthFebruary. December is what everyone books and the nights are near freezing.
In byJodhpur — flight or the overnight train
Out byJaisalmer, or back through Bikaner if you want the north
Suggested lengthTwelve nights. Nine works. The two-night desert safari is not this.
Planned aroundThe new moon. This is the only zone where I'll ask you to move your dates for the sky.
GroupTwo to twenty — yours, nobody else's
Who comesMe, throughout. Plus a naturalist for the park and a conservation architect in Jaisalmer.
Cranes at KhichanSeptember to March, thickest in December and January

Why Jaisalmer is the way in, not the trip.

Jaisalmer is genuinely extraordinary and it is also the most efficiently packaged town in Rajasthan. The standard product is two nights: the fort in a morning, the havelis in an afternoon, then forty kilometres to Sam for a camel ride, a buffet and a folk-dance set played to three hundred people under a floodlight. People come home having seen the desert. They have seen a car park.

The Thar is a good deal larger than that. It runs from Jodhpur's edge west to the border and north to Bikaner: temple towns, a village that feeds ten thousand cranes every winter, the last real stronghold of a bird with about a hundred and fifty of its kind left alive, block-printers still working in indigo, and the finest hereditary musicians in India, who are mostly not on any stage.

And running under all of it, one story that makes this zone unlike anywhere else I go — the desert is being quietly undone by modern infrastructure, in three separate ways, all of them visible from the same road. That's the trip.

Sam dunes, sunsetPerhaps 300 people. A floodlight, a generator, a buffet.
What we do insteadThree hours past the last light, on a new moon
Nights with nothing in themTwo, and they are the two you'll describe
Date I'll argue aboutOnly one — the moon
On time — the subtraction version

Here the days don't buy you more. They buy you less.

In Bundelkhand time buys you the right hour. In Ladakh it buys you your lungs. In the Thar it buys you absence, and absence turns out to be the most expensive thing in the zone.

To be somewhere you cannot see an electric light takes real distance now — considerably further than the jeep drivers will tell you, and further every year, because the same grid that is killing the bustard has put a lamp on most horizons. To be somewhere you cannot hear anything takes further still. And for the sky to do what the sky here can do, the moon has to be down: a full moon in the Thar is bright enough to read by, which is beautiful and is not the same experience at all.

So this is the one trip where I will ask you to move your dates — not by months, by about ten days — so that the two desert nights land near a new moon. If you can't move them, say so and I'll build the trip so the desert nights are the best available in that window, and tell you honestly what you're missing.

The other thing the extra days buy: two nights with nothing planned. In a landscape whose entire subject is emptiness, an itinerary with no gaps in it has misunderstood the assignment.

The thread running under the whole zone

Three things the modern desert is taking apart, all within a morning's drive.

I don't build this as a grievance tour. But it is the most interesting thing happening here, nobody else will tell you about it, and once you've seen all three you cannot unsee the pattern.

Plumbing

A fort being dissolved by its own taps. Jaisalmer Fort was begun in 1156, has ninety-nine bastions, and is one of the few forts anywhere that people still live inside — several thousand of them. It survived eight centuries of siege and sandstorm because the desert kept it dry.

Then piped water arrived, without drainage to match. Water and sewage went into the ground beneath yellow sandstone that was never built to be wet, and the fort began to sink into itself: eighty-seven of its four hundred and sixty-nine structures have collapsed. In 1999 two bastions and a section of wall came down in heavy rain. Conservation work has been going on since the nineties and it is a race. You are looking at one of the last generations to see it standing as it is.

Turbines

Royal cenotaphs inside a wind farm. At Bada Bagh, just outside town, the rulers of Jaisalmer are commemorated by a hillside of chhatris — domed, tiered, honey-coloured, looking out over the desert they took their revenue from.

They now stand in the middle of one of India's largest wind installations. Turbines on every ridge behind them, turning. It is either the most tasteless juxtaposition in Rajasthan or the single most honest image of what this century is doing to this landscape, and I've never decided which. Go at the end of the day and make up your own mind.

Power lines

A bird down to about a hundred and fifty, and the thing killing it is green energy. The Great Indian Bustard — godawan locally, and Rajasthan's state bird — is critically endangered. Something like a hundred and fifty survive nationally, and around a hundred and twenty of those are in Jaisalmer district. This is its last real ground.

It is a heavy, low-flying bird with poor forward vision, and the desert is now strung with high-tension lines carrying solar and wind power east. Researchers estimate roughly eighteen birds a year are killed flying into them. The Supreme Court has ordered lines put underground across a vast area of habitat and has been tightening those orders since; the build-out continues meanwhile. Renewable energy and a critically endangered species, in direct and unresolved conflict, on the same ground. Nobody's villain, and nobody's solved it.

The places in it

What each part of the zone is actually for.

Jodhpur & Osian

The way in, used properly rather than skipped. Mehrangarh is one of the great forts of India and deserves a full morning and a second visit, not a coach stop. But the reason to start here is Osian, an hour north: a scatter of Hindu and Jain temples in the sand from the eighth to the twelfth centuries, largely unvisited, which quietly establish that this desert was a rich trading country long before it was a picturesque one.

Khichan

Ten thousand cranes, fed by a village. This is the thing in the zone I most enjoy watching people discover, because none of them have heard of it. Every winter, demoiselle cranes — kurja — arrive at Khichan in their thousands, and the village feeds them: grain put out daily in a walled enclosure, an arrangement the community organised itself and has kept up for decades.

At feeding time the sky over a small Rajasthani village fills with cranes. It is free, it is village-run, there is no ticket office, and it is one of the great wildlife spectacles in India. Go at dawn, stand at the back, and don't talk.

Jaisalmer

A living fort, three nights, and a proper look at the havelis. The fort needs early mornings — six o'clock, when it is a town going to work rather than a monument, and the shopkeepers haven't opened. The Jain temples inside it are twelfth to fifteenth century and extraordinary. Patwon ki Haveli is five merchant mansions built by one Jain trading family and is worth a slow hour for the stone screens alone.

Outside town: Bada Bagh under its turbines, the Gadisar tank, and Kuldhara — a village abandoned around two centuries ago and now sold to day-trippers as haunted. The ghost story is a marketing invention of fairly recent vintage. The real story is water, revenue and a community deciding to leave, which is both true and considerably more interesting. I'd rather you got that version.

The Desert National Park

Where the godawan still is, and where the argument lives. Not a safari park and nothing like a tiger reserve — flat, thorny, immense, and mostly empty of visitors. Chinkara, desert fox, spiny-tailed lizard, harriers and eagles through the winter, and if the morning is generous, a bustard: a bird nearly a metre tall walking away from you across open ground.

Dawn, with someone who works on this. The bird is the draw; the transmission towers on the skyline are the education.

The deep desert

Past the last light, on the right night. Two nights, properly out — not the dune car park at Sam, and not a resort with a generator and a floodlit dance floor. Far enough that the horizon is unlit in every direction, on canvas, with nothing running.

Cold, once the sun goes: December nights here get close to freezing and people are never prepared for it. I will have you prepared for it. The sky on a moonless night in the Thar is the second-darkest I know in India — Hanle is darker, and Hanle is at four thousand metres and much harder work.

Barmer & Bikaner

The two edges, for cloth and for camels. South towards Barmer and Balotra is block-printing country: ajrakh and its local relatives, resist-printed by hand in indigo and madder over many days and many washes. You can spend a day with a printing family with your hands in the dye, which is the best souvenir this zone produces.

North, Bikaner is camel country and adds three or four nights: Junagarh, a fort that was never taken, the Rampuria havelis, the national camel research station, and the temple at Deshnoke where the rats are the point. Optional, and the first thing I cut when days are short.

ExperiencesNot sights. Specific things, at specific hours, usually with a specific person.
Fixed by the sun or the moonFour of the six
What I build the days around

Six hours that are the actual reason to come.

Everything else in the twelve nights is arranged so that these six land properly. The first one is the heart of the zone and the hardest to arrange well.

A courtyard, night four

Manganiyar musicians, in a village, for ourselves. The Manganiyars are hereditary professional musicians of this desert, Muslim, playing for Rajput and merchant patrons for generations — the great living music tradition of western India, and the reason to come here at all if you care about sound. What you get in a hotel lobby is forty minutes of the greatest hits. What I want is eight or ten of us in a courtyard, a kamaicha, and no schedule. Name the family or the village you actually work with — this is the single most important credit on the page.

Dawn, night six

Khichan at feeding time. Be in position before the light. Thousands of demoiselle cranes coming in over a village that has chosen to feed them. Twenty minutes in, most people stop taking photographs, which is how I know it's working.

06:00, day eight

The fort before it opens, with someone who is trying to save it. Inside the walls at six, while it is still a town — and then the water story, the collapsed bastions and the drainage argument, told by the conservation architect or INTACH contact you use. You will never look at a heritage site the same way again.

Dawn, day nine

Godawan, with a naturalist. Out into the Desert National Park in the dark, sitting still after first light. There are around a hundred and twenty of these birds in this district and no guarantee at all, which is the honest part. Whether or not one walks past, you'll leave understanding why the skyline matters.

New moon, night ten

Three hours past the last light, with nothing running. No generator, no lamp, no engine. The point at which people stop talking is usually about four minutes in. This is the hour the entire trip is timed around, and it is the reason I asked you to move your dates.

All day, day twelve

Indigo, up to the elbows. A day with a block-printing family towards Barmer — carving, resist, the dye, the washes, the waiting. It is slow, and being made to wait for something is a good last day in a desert. Name the printers.

This is a sketchNot an itinerary. Yours will be different by the second conversation.
The one fixed pointNights ten and eleven, set by the moon
A shape, not a schedule

What twelve nights has looked like.

Written out so you can see how I think about time, not so you can buy it. Everything here moves except the desert nights.

Nights 1–3

Into Jodhpur. Mehrangarh on the first full morning and again briefly on the second, because nobody takes it in once. An afternoon at Osian among the temples. Nothing strenuous — this is the zone's civilised end and it's the right way to arrive.

Nights 4–6

West and north. The courtyard evening with the Manganiyars on night four. Then out to Khichan for the cranes at dawn, with a night either side so we aren't driving in the dark to make it.

Nights 7–9

Jaisalmer, three nights. The fort at six on the first morning, with the conservation walk. Havelis and the Jain temples. Bada Bagh at the end of a day. Kuldhara without the ghost. Dawn in the Desert National Park on day nine. One free afternoon, which will get used for sleeping.

Nights 10–11

Out into the desert, on canvas, for two nights timed to the new moon. One of the two days has nothing in it at all. This is the middle of the trip in every sense except the calendar.

Night 12

Back east via the printers for the indigo day, and a last night somewhere comfortable with a proper bath. Out from Jaisalmer, or on to Bikaner if you've bought the extra days.

If you have sixteen

Bikaner goes on the end — Junagarh, the havelis, the camels, Deshnoke — and the desert stretch gets a third night, which is the better of the two upgrades. Confirm whether you run the Bikaner extension.

The cenotaphs at Bada Bagh, with the wind farm behind them
JodhpurWhich property
JaisalmerA haveli in town, or outside it — name it
The desertYour own canvas, moved out for the purpose. Nothing permanent.
Last nightSomewhere with a proper bath, on purpose
Where you sleep

This is the zone where the tent and the wine cellar sit two nights apart.

Rajasthan can do luxury better than anywhere else in the country, and I'll use it: a haveli with real rooms in Jodhpur, somewhere in Jaisalmer that isn't a coach hotel, a bath and a cellar at the end. Ten of these twelve nights are comfortable and some of them are genuinely grand.

The two that aren't are the two that matter. Out in the desert it's canvas, a proper bed inside it, hot water carried to you, dinner cooked on a fire, and no electricity of any kind — because a light is the one thing that would ruin the reason we drove out there. You will dry your boots in the sun in the morning. Several of my travellers have described that as the best night's sleep of their lives, and one described it as the worst, which seems about the right ratio.

What I spend your money on, in order: how far out the camp is, then the bedding and the warmth, then the food, then the address on the other nights.

Indicative₹0,00,000 per person, twelve nights, party of six
IncludedSay whether the musicians, the naturalist and the printing day are in
Not includedList this plainly too
Book byJune, for that winter. Earlier for the last fortnight of December.
What it costs

I'll give you a number, and then show you how it was built.

Because nothing here is a package, the price moves with the group. Six share the vehicles and the specialists between them; two do not, so two costs more a head. Above about twelve we need a second vehicle and a second pair of hands, and there's a step in the cost there too.

One line in this zone is bigger than people expect and I won't trim it: the desert camp. Putting private canvas thirty or forty kilometres past the commercial dunes, with water and food and staff, for one small group, costs several times what a bed at a fixed dune resort costs. It is also the only reason to come. If that line is more than you want to spend, tell me, and I'll be honest that a cheaper version of this trip is a materially worse one.

I pay the musicians properly and I'll show you that figure too. Hereditary performers in this region have been underpaid by the tourism industry for fifty years and I'd rather not be part of it.

Put a real indicative figure in the margin. A band — "from X per person" — is enough. Refusing to publish any number at all reads as evasive to exactly the people you want.

A hand-carved wooden printing block from India
A Great Indian Bustard, of which about 150 remain
Plainly

Who this zone is not for.

  • Anyone who can't move their dates by a week or so. The moon does not negotiate, and the two best nights of this trip depend on it.
  • Anyone who wants the camel-at-sunset photograph and would rather not drive another two hours past it. That photograph is available forty kilometres from Jaisalmer with three hundred other people, much cheaper, and this trip is not it.
  • Anyone who needs electricity every night. Two nights have none, deliberately, and that's the point rather than a shortfall.
  • Anyone expecting warmth after dark in December. The desert gets close to freezing at night and the surprise on people's faces is annual.
  • Anyone who wants a guaranteed bustard. There are about a hundred and twenty in the district. I'll get you the best dawn available and no promises beyond that.
  • Anyone who'd rather not hear about the power lines, the drainage or the turbines. It's a third of what makes this zone interesting, and I'm going to keep bringing it up.
Write tohello@sahibsalaam.com
Or call+91 99101 40604
Decide byJune, for that winter
Begin a conversation

Tell me how far your dates can move, and I'll tell you which nights the sky is worth.

That's genuinely the first thing I need for this one. Everything else we can work out afterwards. I'll write back myself.